Interesting points @Balthazar, good perspective and quite the thought provoking scenario.Balthazar wrote: ↑Sat Aug 29, 2020 3:45 amAt the same time, I feel most of those who own antiques (at least in the online sphere, I know nothing about private collectors) are quite honest about this: Both saying they prefer the tea their antiques brew, due to differences in clay/processing/firing, but also admitting that a part of what they value is something that goes beyond the utilitarian and artistic values of the pots.
You mentioned a metaphysical quality that might hold it's own value. I have not heard this angle mentioned before. I believe this is part of the reason I tend to gravitate to my older pots. There is something about them that is unique, in and of themselves, which transcends utilitarian and artistic value. They have survived generations, and journeyed throughout time and space. They have their own unique, secret, story as it relates to my personal collection. There is a mystique about them that has a powerful allure.
I don't promote one or the other, I can only share my experience, and personal preference. My latest modern pot to join the family is the most costly of the bunch. So my preference is not rooted in monetary value.